|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Archaeological excavation of a presumed Buddhist building and of a Sogdian and karakhanid citadel
Starting point The site of Novopokrovka II lies at the eastern edge of Bishkek, the capital of Kyrgyzstan, in the valley of the Chu River. Its surface is about 14'000 m2. The site was already preliminary explored by P.N. Kozhemjako in 1953.1 He noted two cultural strata and dated the lower one into the 8 th /9 th century A.D., the upper one between the 10 th and 12 th century A.D. In 1965 and 1966 several smaller Buddhist objects were found near the site, among them a stone relief in the Gandhara style, the head of a Buddha made out of clay as well as bronze figures.2 Based on these findings one can assume that Novopokrovka II consists of a Buddhist building, possibly a monastery. Relevance
The Evening paper of Bishkek, September 27 th 2004, excerpts: The excavation's leader Philip Rott, a lecturer at the Russian-Kyrgyz Slavic University Philip Rott comments as follows: Kyrgyzstan is a Klondike for archaeologists. In the valley of the Chu [where, among else, Bishkek and Novopokrovka are located] more than twenty medieval cities and more than fifty settlements are known. But only the ruins of three to four cities remain; the others were changed into waste deposits, cemeteries or even military compounds. Formerly, an art centre was built on Novopokrovka, but the floor quickly started to sink. Therefore it was torn down. We have now started to work there. We are supported by the Swiss Society for the Exploration of EurAsia. Apart from the chums , the archaeologists found in the south-eastern part of the hill strong fortifications. New and interesting discoveries are expected in the future." Continuation of the project During the winter 2004/05, the finds like ten cases of ceramics, coins and the likely two Sogdian inscriptions will be further analyzed. The excavation of the fortification and of the economic complex outside the walls will continue in 2005. ________________________________ 2 Staviskij B. J.: Sud'by buddhisma v Srednei Asii. Moskva 1998. p. 130ff. Excavation 2005: Brief Report Summary The excavation resumed in August/September 2005. The work continued at the south-eastern city wall where the excavation started in 2004. In rooms 1 and 4 (see plan) the lower strata were excavated, which belong to the Karakhanid period, 11 th century A.D. In room 4 a large clay vessel was found; a second large clay oven in room 9; the latter was surely a kitchen. Excavations were continued around the corner tower found in 2004, which belongs to an older horizon and which was probably destroyed prior to the construction of the Karakhanid complex. No traces of fire were found. Two rubbish pits were found with shards. The bottom of the ground has not yet been reached. The north-western part of the excavation revealed an older than Karakhanid horizon, pottery vessels with more archaic shapes and two Turkish coins with Sogdian inscriptions. Such coins were used as off the 8 th till the 11 th century AD. The coins are presently analyzed. In this section at least two rooms (10, 11) were identified.
Project team Valery Kolchenko. Graduate in history Asan Torgoew PD. Dr. Dr. Wassilios Klein
In the earlier, pre- Karakhanid complex within the city wall the excavation of rooms 10-12 was continued. The stratigraphic situation in rooms 11 and 12 is the same. The buried site was covered with a thick layer of clay in the lower parts of the rooms, which means that a significant time span existed between this complex, most likely from the Sogdian period, and the complex that was uncovered outside the city wall, the „ Karakhanid complex“. (Photo 2). Between the epoch of the „Sogdian“ settlement and the Karakhanid complex the location was therefore presumably uninhabited. South of Room 10, Room 11 was uncovered. This room was set in the corner of the city wall, so that the eastern and southern walls are parts of the city walls. In 2006, the post-Sogdian intermediate layer in this room was first removed. Room 12 is north of Room 11. (Photo 3). In the covering rubble of the three rooms and in the ground layer, pottery was found that in principle has different forms from that in the „ Karakhanid complex“(Photo 4). But with the absence of additional coins in Room 11 (in the year 2005, two coins dating from the Turkish period with Sogdian inscriptions were found there) or of other datable artifacts, as yet no accurate dating of this complex is possible. By relative chronology, and judging from the characteristics of the pottery, it is classified as belonging to the so-called „Sogdian“ Phase of the Culture of the Chu Valley.
West of the rooms described above in the upper layer, partially sunk into the intermediate layer, further city structures were uncovered. One of these rooms was partially excavated. Its walls (north and east) were built with brick. The relative chronology and the characteristics of the pottery indicate that this structure is synchronic with the „Karakhanid complex“. This group of rooms as well was built only after the earlier „Sogdian“ settlement had been left by its inhabitants. The architectonic relationship between these rooms and the complex outside the city wall is not yet clarified. In the rooms of the „ Karakhanid “ complex outside the city wall, further digging (Photo 5) and several surveys (drill-holes) were done to ascertain, whether earlier building periods were present here as well. The result is approximately the same in all cases – there are no building structures beneath the Karakhanid floors, that were excavated in 2004-2005. The excavated rooms of the complex were erected on the rubble outside the city wall. In the eastern part of the section, another building structure was found (Photo 6), of which the total excavation was impossible in 2006. It is a brick wall, placed diagonally to the city wall. Found material in this structure is minor; it must be classified as belonging to the „Karakhanid“ period.
During the excavation, ceramic complexes were found that came predominantly from the rubbish pits. Among the metal findings several bronze buckles can be recognized. In the upper layer of the settlement, an important Fals, i.e. a coin from the Karakhanid period, was found of a type (Uzgend, 421), which was unknown until today. This is why this finding is of special importance for numismatics, a relevant publication is in preparation. Finally, the large concrete slab from the 1950's, which covered the city center and rendered any archaeological work in this area impossible, was removed with the help of a bulldozer. (Photo 7)
Plan for 2007 Since the Karakhanid structures outside and along the city wall were extensively explored and sufficient Karakhanid material was obtained, the archaeological work from 2007 on will clearly be concentrated in the direction of the city center. Work in the city center is now possible, thanks to the removal of the concrete slab.
Philipp Rott, Excavation Leader The archeological operations during the excavation campaign of 2007 (Object „Excavation 1“) were concentrated on the early layers of the Karachanidi complex outside the city wall, as these related to the original fortification structures, and partial aspects of the fortification had not yet been finally clarified. This measure was indicated, because the excavation area was to be filled in again. As a result, it can be established for the excavation season of 2007 that the level between the living- and economic complex outside the city walls and the area of excavation showed fill (a filling-in of a cavity with foreign materials) that can be considered a consequence of the destruction of the city wall and the fortification buildings. This fill had been covered with a layer of stone that marks a certain event in the life of the settlement. This hard layer of varied massiveness consists of a combination of fine clay, river pebbles, small bone splinters and ceramic fragments. It can be assumed that this mixture resulted from an inflow of water. Whether this can be attributed to an occurrence of flooding cannot yet be determined at the present state of evaluations. Photo 1 and 2 show the stratigraphic situation under the layer of stone.
Under the fill layer the surface of the platform is recognizable as well. Up to now, it could not be clarified, whether the settlement had been built on an artificially-constructed (man-made) clay platform, or whether the surface of the platform represents a natural terrace. The analysis of a removed sample is yet to be completed. The examination of the fill layer produced important results for the understanding of the existence of the settlement during the Karachanidic period. Above all, it was the numerous waste pits (more than 30!) and their stratigraphic situation that led to the following conclusions. The excavated area was used as waste dump at the beginning of the second settlement phase. The waste pits form rows, as recognizable on the plan, which points to a regular structure (planned installations). The waste pits have various forms, sizes and fillings. Several of them had been dug into the clay platform, others intersect, as can be seen on Photo 3.An interesting fact can be pointed out. In many waste pits, skeletons of dogs were found in complete anatomical order. A cult connection is not established. On Photo 4 an example of this can be seen.
In one of the pits, a piece of a water pipe (Kubur) was found. (Photo 5).
During the excavation campaign of 2007, the settlement was topographically completely documented. For the excavation campaign of 2008, a continuation of the archaeological work is planned with the goal of examining the relationship between the two settlement phases. The research studies will be concentrated on the Sogdian layer. For this purpose, the data and materials obtained in 2007 will provide a solid foundation.
Report about the Excavations at Novopokrovka II 2008 During the excavation campaign of 2008, primary attention was devoted to further investigations of the rooms that were uncovered in 2007 within the city wall, belonging to the earlier building level I (the so-called Sogdian Phase). In addition, three new areas (1-3), i. e., squares (5 x 5 m) were laid out, of which predominantly the upper layers were examined here.
The examination of the rooms that are situated on the east side along the city wall, resulted in the partial uncovering of Room 10. The function of this room at the corner of the city wall remained as yet unclear, so that further excavations will be necessary.
In Room 12, only partially excavated as well, a sunken pit (no.24) was discovered, which contained a ceramic complex, unique to the Cu-valley. Besides early vessel shapes – big chums and vessels that functioned as kettles - there is also a recognizable goblet, which without a doubt represents a unique example for this region. Also rare is the fragment of a so-called smoke vessel with a zigzag-formed rim.
The coin discoveries in 2005, and the relative chronological facts allow the building level (Rooms 10 – 12) to be dated into the 8 th century. It is the task of the next excavation campaign to completely uncover the above-named rooms and to determine their functions. In areas 1 – 3, predominantly the upper layers were uncovered, which were intersected by numerous pits, whereby the culture layer was heavily damaged. It is problematic, moreover, that the upper layers were removed, and/or destroyed during the building of the culture house in the 1950s, and therefore, it remains unclear, from where or from which level the refuse pits were dug. The stratigraphic situation is as follows: under the modern layer is a layer that was intersected by later refuse pits. The material from the pits reveals neither a chronological nor a cultural sequence, since it is not very representative. Under this layer is building level IIa, which can be correlated with the Karachanid phase. The building structures here represent the rooms, the functions of which are unclear. Remnants of a bronze foundry found within them, as well as their provisional character, indicate that they might have been work shops.
The rooms, or more specifically their floors, cover the massive layer, which marks the deterioration of the settlement. It has an heterogeneous structure. In this layer, clay shards and animal bones are found. Noticeable here is a large number of fragments of so-called stands, which are roughly made.
This layer is intersected with refuse pits as well, which further intersect the lower layers. The refuse pits were dug from different levels, i.e. under layers, and contain ceramics and animal bones.
Underneath, building structures were uncovered, which cover over the fillings of rooms from the so-called Sogdian building level (Level I). They represent Level Ib. The poor condition of these structures does not allow for proposals of reconstruction. Level Ib was only partially excavated during the Campaign of 2008.
The excavations of 2008 have shown that between Building Level I, i.e., Ib and II, there was a period of deterioration. In terms of stratigraphy, this period corresponds with the time between the 8 th and 10 th centuries. Historically, this period can be correlated with the invasion of the Karluks. Whether this really had a great effect on the development of city culture in the region is still debatable and can only be answered, when a further number of settlements is excavated over a large area. What led to the deterioration in the settlement territory of Novopokrovka II in this time frame, or what was responsible for it, is still unclear. Furthermore, the question remains, which function the settlement had originally. To examine the existing chronological observations, i.e., to ascertain the original function of the settlement, as well as to answer further questions about the development of the settlement, it was decided to open two new areas (squares) in the central part of the settlement during the campaign of 2009.
Room 15.
To the north, a further room (Room 16), i.e. its southern wall, was
uncovered. Its correlation to Rooms 13-14 is still unclear. In the deterioration
layer of this area, a row of refuse pits was uncovered that reaches
down to the lower layers. Out of Refuse Pit 24/2008, which was completely
uncovered in 2009, a number of heavily corroded coins of the Tyrgesh-type
(most of the coins have a diameter of up to 1 cm) were brought out.
(Fig. 4) In addition to the coins, remnants of bronze casting (wire,
etc.) were found in this pit. Almost all of the refuse pits that can
be correlated with the deterioration layer, contain fragments of ceramics
and animal bones.
The north wall of this room was built of bricks. Additional walls belong
to the beginning period of this complex, i.e. to the earlier horizon
on this settlement, therefore to the 6th-7th cent. A.D. They were built
of pachsa. Along the south and west walls, there are sufas. These sufas
indicate they functioned as residences, which could have changed, however,
in the course of time. It was discovered that they were built after
a certain model. This concerns a special technique, in which the front
wall consists of clay bricks that are laid cross-wise.The maximum height
of the sufas is 38 cm.
In the north wall of the room is a passage to the north that leads
along the eastern wall. To the west, this room connects with Room 16a,
which is only marked by a passage. This passage also runs along the
southern wall. The entire concept, i.e. function of this room remains
unclear, not least because of its destruction by later refuse pits.
This question can therefore only be solved, after Room 16, which is
situated west of it, is excavated.
In square 1d, two building periods were identified. Here we are dealing
with the upper structures, severely damaged by a house of culture built
in the 1950s, the correlations of which have remained unclear. One can
only speak of a wall, built of clay bricks and running in a north-south
direction with a small deviation. The height of this wall is 10 cm,
the thickness – 12 cm. The length of the bricks is 40 cm. Because
of this wall, one can speak of two rooms, Room 1 and 2. Additional constructions
that could be connected to this wall, were not determined. Included in the lower building period (second building period) are additional structures: a room which functioned as a kitchen (Room 3). It contains a tandoor and a floor oven with an ash reservoir, the upper parts of which were destroyed through later building work, so that only their lower parts were found intact. The tandoor has a diameter of 64 cm, its height is 30 cm. In the fill of the tandoor, remains of a water jug were found.
The floor oven has an opening towards the west. The measurements: north-south
– 27 cm, heigth – 20 cm. North of the oven is a reservoir,
which was used for ash. A similar kitchen room was discovered in 2004
near Room 9.
In Square 1a, a row of refuse pits was uncovered, which had been deepened
by the upper layer. Additional work, i.e. examinations of lower layers
on this level are planned for 2010. A large room (Room 12), belonging to the original period of the complex
within the city walls, i.e. the earlier horizon, was completely uncovered.
The function of this room is not yet totally clear, since it is not
known, how this room can be correlated with others next to it. To clarify
this is one of the goals for Season 2010. Through the excavation of
a number of additional rooms (Rooms 10, 11) along the eastern city wall,
it will be made clear, how this important area, which was connected
to the fortification, can be viewed. Unique ist the ceramic complex
that stems from this horizon. For the Chu-Valley, this may be the richest,
closed complex containing forms that indicate relatively distinct relationships
with the Syr-Darya region. In Sogd, the ceramic forms obtained here
do not find any clear parallels. Practically for the first time with
regard to the Chu-Valley, we can thus speak of an earlier building technique. Scientific publications will follow. In the series „Materials
and Investigations in the Archaeology of Kyrgyzstan) (starting in 2010),
the publication of yearly excavation reports is planned.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||